My first grade daughter has been through various stages of writing with English, Chinese, and Korean since she was a toddler. Her weekly dictation journal has been one of the best resources, and I think many kids could benefit from this.
Writing takes significant time to master and requires coordination of complex cognitive and physical skills.
Before a child can write independently, she must organize her ideas and master the physical mechanics.
Dictation – the act of writing what someone else has said – can bridge the gap between speaking and writing.
In this post, I will explain:
- Benefits of a dictation journal
- When to consider dictation
- Examples dictation strategies
- “Sharing the pen” and transition to independent writing
- Copywork and dictation
- Digital alternatives to handwriting
1. How a dictation journal improves speaking, reading, and writing
By removing the physical task and concentrating on self-expression, my daughter’s speaking, reading and writing skills have all improved with her dictation journal.
If your child has a private language teacher or if you’re helping your child acquire language skills, a dictation journal is worth adding to the routine.
Through a dictation journal, a teacher can demonstrate:
- That writing is meaningful and important
- How to form alphabet letters into words or Chinese strokes into characters
- Correct use of punctuation and spacing
- Patience with listening to speech and writing associated words
2. When to start implementing a dictation journal
For toddlers, dictation can begin by labeling with a word or phrase.
In the early elementary years, a teacher or parent can help with dictating sentences or even regular journal entries.
As a child matures, she takes on the role of careful listening and note-taking during class.
For multilingual children, language skills can be quite variable depending on exposure and opportunity for fluency.
Therefore, a child may be ready for dictation in one language but not the other.
Alternatively, a child may be ready to journal independently in one language but benefit from prolonged dictation in the other.
3. Examples of dictation strategies
(1) Toddlers and preschoolers
After drawing a picture, I would praise my child’s effort and ask her to describe the art.
Since Mandarin is one of our family’s minority languages, I focus on encouraging Chinese dialogue.
If my daughter gave permission, I would label the picture with what she said.
When she was young, this could be one word “花 (huā / flower). Eventually, this would progress full sentence “三朵花在草地上 (Sān duǒ huā zài cǎodì shàng / 3 flowers are on the ground).”
Blank spaces can be filled to create a print-rich environment – but only with the child’s consent!
(2) Ways to use a dictation journal with elementary school students
a) Dictation of personal experiences
When my daughter was 5, her Chinese teacher tried to introduce journaling, but my daughter had no interest for a few months.
This was surprising to me as she had been motivated to do copywork and writing greeting cards in Chinese.
However, after my daughter read 米小圈上学记 series last summer and seeing her teacher’s childhood diary, she was inspired to start her own journal.
Over the past half year, this dictation journal has been a very fun part of my daughter’s Chinese tutoring sessions.
Speaking in only Chinese, teacher would ask my daughter to describe herself, her brother, and other important life experiences.
While verbally repeating back what my daughter said, she would take notes in the journal and point out new Chinese characters.
After class, my daughter has enjoyed re-reading the diary entries to herself or out loud to me!
Here’s is a video of my daughter reading an entry about her friend.
b) Dictation of creative, fictional content
For fun, my daughter has tried dictating a few creative pieces inspired by adventures from losing her first few baby teeth.
These exercises stretch her imagination and give her a chance to explore storytelling!
c) Dictation of literature and history analysis
At the start of first grade (classical conversations school), my daughter’s homework was to dictate 1-2 sentence reflections of history and English literature books.
In school, they call this a “narration journal.”
After reading a chapter of Story of the World for example, I would ask her what was most memorable and then write down what she said.
However, since my daughter has been writing English letters for a few years, she felt comfortable with writing in her journal.
So after we read a book:
- She tells me what she thinks
- I write it down on scrap paper
- She copies each sentence into her journal
4. Copywork with dictation journal
As mentioned in the above example, dictation can be used in combination with copywork or separately.
While a child is learning to express themselves verbally, they can work on building confidence through tracing worksheets or copying something of interest.
I’ve shared before how my daughter chooses favorite Chinese songs and English bible verses for self-motivated copywork which you can learn more about in this article.
5. “Sharing the pen” and transitioning to independent journaling
The page number “45” in the above image reveals that learning to journal has been a very gradual process.
Since my daughter is gradually better at memorizing Chinese characters, she and her teacher take turns writing in her journal.
Over 40 pages were written by the teacher before my daughter felt ready to write in her journal!
Currently, they are still “sharing the pen”: she writes when Chinese characters that she writes with confidence, while her teacher fills in the rest.
In multilingual children, skills can vary with each language component. Despite my daughter’s Chinese reading level being far more advanced than English, the writing levels are reversed.
In any case, following the child’s pace remains important for building confidence and self-motivation to learn.
6. Digital alternatives to a dictation journal
For those who find handwriting too cumbersome, typing is an alternative but comes with the downside of screen time.
However, programs like the Book Creator app can be very encouraging for students to dictate their ideas and publish an e-book!
We haven’t explored any digital strategies yet, and I will update this post in the future when we have new experiences and insight to share!
Have you tried dictation strategies with your child or student?
Please share your experience in the comments below!
We’d love to hear what has or hasn’t worked for your family.
If this concept is new to you, feel free to forward this article to your teacher or school!
More teaching tips for multilingual kids
- How to encourage and maximize the minority language
- Ways to improve listening and speaking
- Creating a prepared environment for reading
- Writing ideas and worksheets
Let’s stay in touch
As always, let me know if you have any questions, and I’ll try my best to answer them.
The best way to connect is by leaving a note in the comments so all readers can learn from the discussion 🙂
Follow me on Facebook where I share my latest posts as well as favorite articles about children’s education, Chinese resources, and hands-on activities!
On Instagram, I share activity highlights and how we integrate learning Chinese & Korean (minority languages) in our daily life.
And I’d love to chat more with you about favorite books at @chinesekidlit!